





Shop Mothering
Join MotheringDotCommunity
My 2 1/2 year old son only ever wants his Daddy, and has had a strong preference for him since around the age of 10 months. I know this is unusual. He does have a 2 month old little sister, but this was going on long before her birth. He still nurses on demand (and often doesn't want me to touch him even when nursing), I stay at home with him and in fact hardly ever leave him, I actually miss him when I do and do not like to be away from him. I practice the parenting style suggested in your books, validate him, try to be gentle of and respect him. We do have fun together when he is happy. However, for the most part, he does not let me touch him, love him, hug him, hold him, only Daddy is allowed to pick him up.
When he gets hurt or scared or upset it is Daddy even though I try to comfort him, validate him, help him. I am completely 100% there for him. It has been hard for me. I even for the longest time have taken a step back and just been gentle and validated his need for Daddy, staying with him while upset and wait for Daddy to come over to him. My son has always been high needs, easily upset and a lot of your suggestions in your book do not work with him. He never calms down. We try and try and can never calm him down.
So I guess it boils down to two issues: My son can never be calmed down, and he NEVER wants Mommy, only ever Daddy. He also has a need to always hold something such as cloth wipes, keys, or other objects that work for his hands like someone else said in a different question. But my main concern is not letting Mommy touch him and pick him up, help him and love him. Not even diaper changes, even those are Daddy. Why would it be this way? What could have caused it, and how could I change things, although I have tried everything in the world?
Dear perplexed mother,
The reasons for your son’s preference for his father can be many. Without speaking to you directly, I cannot give real advice. I can, however, make a few suggestions that may or may not fit.
The most common reason for a child preference for his dad is simply that daddy is fun and mom is service and chores. If you can be more playful and goofy, you may see a difference. Another common error that leads to such a preference is the way dad treats mom. Your son maybe learning that mom is not the focus of love because she is not dad’s focus of love. The solution in this case would be to spend time together, so your child can be with both of you and see daddy loving mommy. Your husband can say, “Lets go play with mommy, I love mommy,” and be with you and hug and kiss you and have a good time together.
Other reasons can be something about your way with your child. You could be too affectionate or overbearing; some wee once don’t like so much touch. Or, it is possible that, loving as you obviously are, he does not feel connected. You say that he never calms down indicates to me that you see validation as a tool to calm a child down. Validation has no goal to calm down. The validated child may cry even more because the validation gives recognition to his hurt and permission to fully express himself. Or, you may being validating with words that insult him or read his feelings.
Children sense our intend even when we don’t show it. When you expect your words to stop his crying, he may see you as not accepting him the way he is, resisting his nature and even not loving him. He doesn’t want to calm but to fully express himself as long as he needs. In addition, I wonder what is the cause of some of the crying. There could be something in your way with him that leaves him feeling not accepted by you and unhappy.
I must stress again that these guesses may be close of far from helpful. I am confident that if I speak or meet you and your family in person, I can assist you in resolving this confusing and painful relationship with your child. He wants a loving connection with you as much as you want it. The confusion can be cleared. If you wish to speak with me, you can sign up for a phone session on my site at: http://naomialdort.com/guidance.html
Warmly, Naomi Aldort, http://authenticparent.com/