Jennifer Margulis

Mothering Outside the Lines

“Maybe She Just Looks Puny Compared to MY Baby”

February 23rd, 2010

Yesterday Baby Leone, Etani, and I walked two miles to pick up Athena from school. The stepmother of one of Athena’s classmates was there, so I got to see her son, who was born three days after Leone, for the first time.

The babies smiled at each other.

“How much does she weigh?” The mom asked me.

“I don’t know,” I began. “We don’t–”

“She’s so tiny,” she interrupted.

“Tiny?”

“Well, maybe she just looks puny compared to MY baby,” she said. “He weighs fifteen pounds!”

Of all the adjectives I would use to describe Leone, “puny” isn’t one of them. She’s like a sumo wrestler with so many chins you can’t see her neck. She has chubby thighs and a Buddha belly. I don’t get it. Was it because she had a boy that this mom was sure her son was bigger than my daughter? The most bizarre part is that we weighed Leone at the Y a few weeks ago and she was fifteen pounds then so she probably actually weighs more now than the other mom’s baby.

“First time mom?” My friend Victoria, whose kids are 10 and 7, asked on the phone when I told her about it later that day. Etani was in the tub while Leone sat on my lap and watched him splash around. Athena was drawing, Hesperus at gymnastics.

“Uh huh.”

“That explains it!” Victoria cried. “You say–and think–all sorts of crazy things when you’re a new mom! You know that as well as anybody.”

I remember coming out of a restaurant with Hesperus in Atlanta when she was just a few weeks old and bumping into a new mom with a baby around the same age. We started comparing height and length and percentiles, as breathless and oblivious to anything but our own babies as teenagers in love, and as fierce in our comparison as if we were talking dick size not head circumference. My dad rolled his eyes and moved away from us. With ten years of hindsight, I realize now that my dad must have been embarrassed by the meaninglessness of our conversation.

I’ve been at this long enough that the puny remark shouldn’t have got my hackles up. But it did. I thrust Leone into the other mom’s arms.

“Here,” I said. “Hold her. She’s pretty hefty.”

Leone immediately started to fuss. Athena took her. She quieted right down in her sister’s arms.

Why do you think new moms act competitive with each other? Have you ever inadvertently insulted another mom’s baby? How do you respond when people you barely know say hurtful things? Should I have responded differently? I’m really looking forward to reading your thoughts in the comment section below.

Tags: , , ,

[ 12 comments ]

The American Prejudice Against Big Families

October 29th, 2009
Athena, 3; Etani, 8 months; Hesperus, 5

Athena, 3; Etani, 8 months; Hesperus, 5

I understand why people raise their eyebrows at us for being pregnant with our fourth baby.

The vast majority of Americans still only have two children but there is a small subset of the population creating such large families that one Women’s Health writer suggests the craze for more children stems from an addiction to being pregnant. She argues that women become pregnant because they like being treated like rock stars and being in the limelight and she dubs women like me with more than two children “bumpaholics.”

(I don’t know about you but my experience being pregnant in America has not involved red carpet treatment strewn with rose petals and last time I checked having stretch marks, morning sickness, leg cramps, hemorrhoids, insomnia, and a myriad of other pregnancy side effects did not equate to achieving celebrity status, but a rant against the arguments in this unsubstantiated article—which was written by a writer I respect and consider a friend—is off the topic of today’s post).

Etani 3; Hesperus, 7; Athena 5

Etani 3; Hesperus, 6; Athena 5

Though I think the argument that some women are addicted to pregnancy is specious at best, I understand why people feel judgmental about big families. I am very concerned about the environment and fear global warming with an anxiety that manifests itself in the pit of my stomach every day:

My kids: Why can’t we drive Mommy? We don’t want to walk/take the bus/bike today.

Me: Because we homo sapiens are going to pollute ourselves out of existence like the cyanobacteria! The polar ice caps are melting and polar bears are drowning and WE ARE NOT DRIVING NO MATTER WHAT!

A recent study by researchers at Oregon State University suggests that the best way to reduce your carbon footprint is to have fewer children (or no children at all).

I worry about overpopulation.

I worry because I want my children to feel special and loved and cared for, and I want to be the best parent I can be for each of them, and my time feels pretty divided already (especially when everyone’s talking at once at dinner), and I wonder what will happen when I have to turn my attention to caring for a newborn.

I worry because, like so many others, our finances are not nearly as robust (read: we’re broke and money is a big concern) in this down economy as they should be to have a big family and I read things in magazines like “you should have six months of savings no matter what.” We don’t have six days of savings.

My son Etani, who just turned six, asks for another hug at bedtime. He smells warm and salty when I kiss that soft place on his neck a hundred times. “Goodnight Pineapple,” he whispers patting my stomach. “I love you.”

There are lots of legitimate arguments against having even one child. Our new baby isn’t here yet but already I know that our lives will be much richer and more meaningful when he or she is in it.

Etani, 6; Athena, 8; Hesperus, 10

Etani, 6; Athena, 8; Hesperus, 10

Tags: , , ,

[ 19 comments ]



Ad Slot: mothering-misc-medium-rectangle-right-300x250-FR

     
     

Discussions

     DISCUSSIONS                 JOIN NOW or SIGN IN

Pleeease look at my chart!! posted by klocke, Today 06:18:05 PM
My 9 month old will only nap in my arms-help posted by Cindy-Lou, Today 06:17:55 PM
My son fell into the pool posted by Little grey mare, Today 06:17:31 PM
Why did my legs hurt during labor? posted by Evergreen, Today 06:16:23 PM

Shop Mothering

Shop Mothering:
Canvas Bag

Be one of the first to get this limited edition canvas bag!